FT	New York City FC	2-3	Columbus Crew
39	Mitja Ilenič	0 - 0
44	Agustín Ojeda	1 - 0
HT		1 - 0
48		1 - 1	Christian Ramirez
53		1 - 2	Mohamed Farsi
65		1 - 3	Cucho Hernández
86	Santiago Rodríguez	2 - 3
FT		2 - 3